Open here Open here
25 2014

America’s Top 10 Ice Cream Parlors

salt-and-straw-header

Well isn’t this just the sweetest list you’ve ever seen – and perfectly timed for summer. Based on your reviews and opinions on TripAdvisor, we’ve got the scoop on the 10 top ice cream parlors in the U.S.

 

You’ve got good taste…literally. Some of the flavors these spots are known for sound out of this world. Take a look below and start thinking about whether you want it in a cone or a cup…

 

1. Island Creamery, Chincoteague Island, Virginia (868 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Since 1975, this island “sweetery” has been serving decadent varieties of homemade ice cream made daily. Guests can enjoy heavenly flavors such as Bourbon Caramel Crunch, Cotton Candy Party, and Java Jolt atop a freshly baked waffle cone. A TripAdvisor reviewer commented, “We had the Caramel Bourbon, Salty Caramel, Birthday Cake, and Vanilla flavors – each were wonderful and the homemade waffle cones were delightful.”

 

island-creamery

Island Creamery

 

 

2. Dietsch Brothers Inc., Findlay, Ohio (109 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Located 100 miles north of Columbus, this sweet shop prides itself on quality over quantity, serving up ice cream and candy made from the finest ingredients. Delectable homemade creations include Caramel Macchiato, German Chocolate, Peach, Caramel Cashew, and more. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “The Dietsch Family has been around for generations and the quality has not changed. This is a must stop if you are in Findlay.”

 

Dietsch Brothers Inc.

Dietsch Brothers Inc.

 

 

3. Super Scoops Inc., Treasure Island, Florida (293 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Offering more than 20 flavors including Carrot Cake and Captain’s Butterscotch, travelers can enjoy their scoops in a waffle cone or bowl, milkshake, banana split or loaded sundae. Those looking for lighter fare can choose from tasty low-fat or sugar-free options. “It’s a quaint little spot with delicious ice cream – a perfect way to end the day at the beach,” said a TripAdvisor reviewer.

 

Super Scoops Inc.

Super Scoops Inc.

 

 

4. Woodside Farm Creamery, Hockessin, Delaware (101 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Located approximately 50 miles north of Dover, this suburban shop offers eclectic ice cream flavors such as Dirt – made up of gummy worms with crushed chocolate cookies; and Motor Oil – coffee ice cream mixed with green-colored caramel and fudge swirl. A TripAdvisor reviewer commented, “This wonderful family-owned creamery is in a lovely area of Delaware. Bring the kids, they can say hello to the cows that produce the milk for the delicious ice cream.”

 

Woodside Farm Creamery

Woodside Farm Creamery

 

 

5. A Better Scoop, Englewood, Florida (108 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Travelers visiting Florida’s Gulf Coast can beat the heat with a cool cone at A Better Scoop. Boasting more than 40 indulgent flavors, those with a sweet tooth will surely get their fix after sampling creations like Toasted Coconut, Georgia Peach, and Salted Caramel. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “The smell of the freshly made waffle cones hits you as soon as you walk through the door. The huge selection of flavors and great atmosphere make this a must-visit place for anyone in the area!”

 

 

A Better Scoop

A Better Scoop

 

 

6. Rococo Artisan Ice Cream, Kennebunkport, Maine (129 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Inspired by Argentinean ice cream, this savory shop produces small batches that are blended slowly for perfect taste and texture. The eatery boasts a rotating menu of 14 daily artisanal flavors including Chai Cardamom, Sweet Avocado Cayenne, and Nutella Cranberry. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “We loved every flavor we tried (the ingredients are exotic, but somehow they all conspire towards deliciousness) and the quaint setting was perfect for an evening stroll.”

 

Rococo Artisan Ice Cream

Rococo Artisan Ice Cream

 

 

7. Salt & Straw, Portland, Oregon (412 reviews, 4.5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

Crafted using 17 percent butterfat milk, patrons of this Portland parlor can enjoy incredibly creamy cones in flavors ranging from the unique Black Raspberries and Smoked Ham to gourmet takes on the classics such as Double Fold Singing Dog Vanilla. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “Flavors are adventurous, the waffle cones are freshly made and warm, and you can sample before you buy.”

 

Salt & Straw

Salt & Straw

 

 

8. Martha’s Dandee Creme, Queensbury, New York (158 reviews, 5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

In the Lake George region of Upstate New York, this roadside retreat publishes a monthly flavor calendar to help fervent fans to plan their visit. Tempting variations of their signature soft serve include Banana Chocolate Twist, Pistachio, and Black Raspberry. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “I’ve been a customer for so many years now, and Martha’s never disappoints. Their prices are great, especially given the insane amount of ice cream they give you.”

 

Martha's Dandee Creme

Martha’s Dandee Creme

 

 

9. Bi-Rite Creamery & Bakeshop, San Francisco, California (375 reviews, 4.5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)
Using organic milk from a nearby farm and rarely containing more than five ingredients per flavor, this shop treats travelers to decadent hard or soft scoops. Staple favorites include Salted Caramel, Roasted Banana and Honey Lavender, while Balsamic Strawberry and Earl Grey are seasonally available sensations. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “One spoon of this heavenly ice cream and I was sold! They have so many different flavors – absolutely unique and so creamy!”

 

Bi-Rite Creamery & Bakeshop

Bi-Rite Creamery & Bakeshop

 

 

10. Sunset Icecream Parlor, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania (151 reviews, 4.5 out of 5 bubbles on TripAdvisor)

In downtown Gettysburg, travelers can satisfy their sweet cravings by indulging in one of this shop’s history-inspired creations including the Yankee Hurrah – coffee ice cream with hot fudge, malt and peanuts; or the Rebel Yell – vanilla and chocolate with chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and malt. A TripAdvisor reviewer said, “The ice cream is amazing. It’s wonderful to sit on the porch or at the picnic tables in the evening and people watch while having a sundae or a cone.”

 

Sunset Icecream Parlor

Sunset Icecream Parlor

 

 

Is your local favorite missing from the list? Give it a shout out in the comments!

Categories: Top 10 Lists, Travel Inspiration

4 thoughts on “America’s Top 10 Ice Cream Parlors

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>